As we are officially in the midst of the pie making season, I decided to make some too – vegan pies with mushrooms. Theses savoury vegan pies are deliciously moreish yet much easier to make than you would expect. They make for a delicious meatless main whether you are vegan yourself or hosting a vegan guest this Thanksgiving or Christmas.
This recipe makes four individual vegan pies but if there are only two of you, for example, you could simply freeze half of the pastry and filling for a rainy day – you’ll be glad to find it in the depth of your freezer one day, when your body is crying out for some comfort food.
While I typically make my favourite vegan Wellington for Christmas, this year I am planning to bring these vegan pies with mushrooms to the family Christmas instead. As we are the only two people who do not eat turkey at Christmas making two delicious pies rather than a big centerpiece makes much more sense. I also like the fact that these vegan pies are made with homemade pastry, which is always so much nicer than any shop bought. These vegan pies are very satisfying and packed with umami. The filling comprises of three different types of mushrooms – each delivering their unique texture and flavour. The mushrooms are the star, but the backing singers of white wine, thyme and black garlic all work together to deliver a real punch of flavour. I hope you’ll want to give these a try ahead of your hosting and I do hope they win your heart as much as they’ve won ours.
VEGAN BUTTER: Use a tried and tested brand of vegan butter block to make the pastry. If you live in the UK, I recommend seeking out Naturli. It is sold in both Sainsburys and Waitrose as well as independent health food stores. If you cannot find it, my second recommendation is Violife and finally unsalted Flora. All of them work well enough.
MUSHROOMS: I used a combination of different mushrooms to get a variety of textures and flavours. I used 300 g / 10.5 oz of chestnut mushrooms and 150 g / 5.3 oz (each) of oyster mushrooms and shiitake, but any combination of mushrooms will work. If all you can find is regular white mushrooms, don’t worry, they will work on their own too.
BLACK GARLIC: Black garlic is an unusual ingredient that pairs with mushrooms wonderfully well. It has a funky sweet and tangy flavour, reminiscent of balsamic vinegar. Big UK supermarkets carry black garlic in their herb aisles but if you can’t find it, don’t worry – a little of quality balsamic vinegar and a pinch of sugar will boost the flavours of the filling too.
PLAIN FLOUR: I used regular plain flour (known as all purpose flour to my US audience, I think) to make the pastry. It’s a staple ingredient so I am sure you won’t have any trouble with it.
ONION & GARLIC: Onion and garlic need no explanation, I am sure. They are how most good savoury recipes start…
THYME: Thyme and mushrooms are a classic combination so that’s why I chose to use thyme here, but herbs like sage or rosemary will also work. Be sure to add them to taste, start off with a teaspoon of chopped fresh herbs and add more if the taste is too subtle for your palate.
WINE: Wine wine adds flavour and a hit of acidity to the filling for these vegan pies. If you are worried about alcohol, let me reassure you that the alcohol content cooks out in the 10 minute simmering time. If are still worried, simply use quality veggie or mushroom stock instead of wine.
VEGAN CREAM: Vegan cream adds thickness and body to the filling. I used Oatly single cream but anything similar will work. And if you have trouble finding vegan single cream, blend 100 g (¾ cup) of cashews soaked in boiling water for 30 minutes first with about half a cup of water until silky smooth.
SOY SAUCE: Soy sauce seasons the filling nicely but it also contributes a lovely depth of flavour that works with mushrooms so well.
Make the filling by pan-frying the mushrooms in a bit of olive oil until browned. You want to do that in two batches as it’s important not to overcrowd the pan for best results. While the mushrooms are cooking down, you can start on the sauce to which you add the mushrooms eventually.

You want to end up with a glossy, full of umami filling that’s wet enough to coat individual mushrooms but not so wet that it will make your pastry soggy. You can control that by adding a splash of water of the pan is looking too dry or adding a touch more cornstarch if the filling is wetter than it should be.

If you want to make a simple shortcrust pastry, put all of the dry ingredients in the food processor. Add very cold (I recommend popping them into the freezer for a bit) cubed butter and using the pulse function cut it into the flour until there are no large pieces of butter left. Then trickle in JUST ENOUGH of ice-cold water mixed in with vodka until the pastry is sufficiently hydrated to clump together. Gather, wrap in clingfilm and rest for several hours or overnight. If you are in a rush, rest it in the fridge for 30 minutes and freezer for another 30.

What I did, is a version of above – it’s a little trickier but the resulting pastry is not just tender but also flaky. So I started with half of the flour and half of the butter, which I pulsed together. Next, I added the other half of the flour and butter but I only pulsed it twice before adding JUST ENOUGH ice-cold liquid to enable me to gather the dough together – I want larger pieces of butter in the final product to create layers. Once I added enough liquid, I transferred the dough onto a work bench and formed it into a rough rectangle. I used a bench scraper to chop the dough in half and to stack one half on top of the other. I then flattened the dough again with a floured rolling pin and repeated the stacking once more time. After two stacks, I formed the dough into a circle, covered it in cling film and rested it. Below is the picture of what my dough looks like in cross section – those bigger pieces of butter and the stacking create flaky layers in your pastry.


Roll chilled dough on a lightly floured surface until it’s about 3 mm / 1/8 inch thick. Cut out four 14 cm / 5.5 inch diameter circles to line the bottom of the mould and four 9 cm / 3.5 inch lids. Gently line the pie moulds with the larger pieces being careful not to stretch the pastry. Make an opening in the lids and refrigerate both once more – you want them to be cold before baking. Just before baking, fill each pie with the filling, pop the lid on top, apply glaze to the lids with a brush and bake until golden, about 25-30 minutes. Allow the pies to cool down and settle before removing from the moulds.



MUSHROOM FILLING
MUSHROOM FILLING
ASSEMBLY
*VEGAN BUTTER: use vegan butter than comes in a solid block (I like Naturli) rather than the spreadable kind in a tub.
*MUSHROOMS: I used 300 g / 10.5 oz of chestnut mushrooms and 150 g / 5.3 oz (each) of oyster mushrooms and shiitake.
The pastry recipe is adapted from this recipe.